SPY vs QQQ

Discussion in 'Trading' started by Jdesey, Mar 30, 2025 at 10:45 PM.

  1. Jdesey

    Jdesey

    asked in options but will ask here. It seems to me that SPY is preferred for short term trading vs. QQQ. I assume that is because SPY is more diversified and not so tech heavy. As well it is somewhat less volatile. I guess if I had to do just one it would be SPY. opinions?
     
  2. PPC

    PPC

    Instead of assuming and guessing, post your backtesting stats for both the SPY and the QQQ, and then we’ll provide objective answer..

    You haven’t done the backtesting, have you? Which is why you’re asking.

    In other words, if you want to be a trader, you must do your own research and not rely on others to spoon-feed you.

    I can guarantee you one thing: until you begin to treat trading as a business and not as a hobby, you won’t succeed.
     
  3. my test shows qqq has better returns
     
  4. maxinger

    maxinger

    talk about day trading futures
    ES NQ RTY YM

    YM tends to be a little less volatile.

    ES NQ - not much different in volatility
    So No point splitting hairs.
     
    PPC likes this.
  5. 2rosy

    2rosy

    Code:
    Ticker         SPY         QQQ         DIA
    count   699.000000  699.000000  699.000000
    mean      0.000652    0.000798    0.000544
    std       0.009890    0.013301    0.008527
    min      -0.044456   -0.056397   -0.040364
    25%      -0.004773   -0.006924   -0.004406
    50%       0.000608    0.000927    0.000730
    75%       0.006351    0.008829    0.005498
    max       0.053497    0.071193    0.035984
     
    Sekiyo likes this.