Do you not understand, there is someone getting paid to MANUALLY go through 764 pages of thread here and tally up all the trades that have been made by B1S2....
Are you not understanding what is happening here? B1S2 does not post trading statements. He simply posts entries (and sometimes exits) in this thread. If he posts trading statements and summary pics, it must be elsewhere. What the guys here are trying to do is just parse what he has posted in this journal with what he has typed, to get an idea of how honest he has been in his own journal? That is the gist of it.
Number of contracts is irrelevant, because with no contract number call per call, we can just assume they are all 1 contract per trade, and work the rest from there. It is called "extrapolation".
Yes, if the results are heavily to one side, we can assume the overall results are in that direction.
Finally ! That's all I needed to hear. This is stupid. Statements are the gospel of trading. Anything else can be contrived and not trusted. If he is making calls and they are not being posted in a brokerage account, then they can be fictitious.
1) He's down a lot. 2) @Buy1Sell2's own tallies are completely removed from reality. The dude told me that it made it all worthwhile. It's comically fraudulent. 3) It's no surprise that I get blocked when it's mentioned that "the reckoning" is at hand. B1S2 made it up. Just pulled numbers out of his ass. The actual numbers don't lie. And yes, B1S2 will undoubtedly use the hindsight call option of stating that the winners were on large size and losers on one lots. 0 f*cks given.
I haven't followed this thread enough to know about his calls. I was just saying if his winners and losers are not that far apart, then size can matter. But if the vast majority of his trades are losers, then yeah we can assume he's lost a lot of money.